SICE JCMSI Review Form

1. Paper Information

   Title of the paper:
   Author(s):
   Paper ID:

2. Referee Information

   Name:
   Affiliation:
   E-mail:
   Date:

3. Evaluation (Select the most appropriate ones)

   Contribution: Significant / Good / Minor / None
   Quality: Excellent / Good / Fair / Poor
   Paper award candidate: Strong / Good / Marginal / Substandard

4. Recommendation (Select the most appropriate one)

   A. Publish without re-review.

   Minor revisions are required if necessary.
   
   

   B. Publish subject to revision.

   Significant changes are required as indicated by Comments to the Author(s). Revised paper should be checked carefully by associate editor (and referee if necessary).
   
   

   C. Not publishable.

   Detailed comments are provided in Comments to the Author(s).

5. Confidential Comments to the Editorial Staff

   (Motivate your evaluation and recommendation)

6. Comments to the Author(s) [Required]

   (Use a separate sheet if necessary)